A data warehouse stores cleaned data in a structure designed before the data arrives, and it suits repeatable reporting. A data lake stores data in its native format and applies structure when you query it, and it suits data engineering and exploration. In the data lake vs data warehouse decision, choose by who runs the queries and how often they repeat.
That is the whole argument, and the rest of this guide shows where it comes from. We use the criteria Microsoft and AWS publish rather than our own, add a comparison table, and finish with the questions we ask clients before they commit to either.
What a Data Warehouse Does
AWS's comparison describes a warehouse as holding relational data from transactional systems and business applications. The data is curated and serves as the central version of the truth. AWS lists the fastest query results using local storage, and batch reporting, BI and visualizations as typical uses.
In practice that means three things. The data is structured: tables with defined columns, types and relationships. The data is processed before it lands: an ETL or ELT step standardizes formats, applies business rules and removes duplicates, so the numbers in two reports agree. And the structure is designed up front, which AWS calls schema-on-write. That design work is the cost of a warehouse, and it is also the reason business users can query one without help.
Azure Synapse, Fabric Warehouse, Snowflake, BigQuery and Amazon Redshift are common platforms. If you are planning one, see our data warehousing services. Our guides cover whether you need a data warehouse at all, how to choose a data warehouse platform, and warehouse architecture patterns.
What a Data Lake Does
AWS describes a lake as holding all data, structured, semi-structured and unstructured, with the schema written at the time of analysis. The data can be curated or raw. AWS lists machine learning, exploratory analytics and streaming among the typical uses.
A lake accepts anything: database exports, JSON from an application, CSV from a supplier, logs, images, sensor readings. Nothing is transformed on the way in, which is why loading a lake is cheap and fast and why the lake is the natural place to keep the original copy of everything. The work moves to the point of use. Whoever queries the lake has to know what the files mean, which is why lakes are used by data engineers and data scientists far more than by business users.
Azure Data Lake Storage Gen2 and Amazon S3 are common platforms. A lake can add an open table format such as Delta Lake or Apache Iceberg to get warehouse-style reliability. That layered approach is a lakehouse, and we explain it in What Is a Data Lakehouse?
Schema on Read vs Schema on Write
The phrase that separates the two is schema. Schema-on-write, the warehouse approach, defines the structure before data is stored. A row that does not fit is rejected or fixed on the way in. Schema-on-read, the lake approach, stores the data as it arrives and applies a structure when someone queries it.
A concrete example: a supplier changes its invoice export and adds a column. In a warehouse, the load fails until someone updates the table and the pipeline, and no bad data gets in. In a lake, the new files land fine, and the first query that assumes the old layout returns wrong results until someone notices. Neither behaviour is better. One protects the reports, the other protects the raw data.
Data Lake vs Data Warehouse: Side by Side
| Data lake | Data warehouse | |
| Data types | Raw, structured, semi-structured and unstructured | Cleaned, processed, structured |
| Schema | On read, applied at query time | On write, defined before loading |
| Processing | ELT: load raw, transform when needed | ETL: transform before loading |
| Primary purpose | Exploration, machine learning, streaming, keeping the original copy | BI, standard reports, dashboards |
| Typical users | Data engineers, data scientists | Analysts, finance, operations, executives |
| Performance | Varies with file layout and engine | Fast and predictable for known queries |
| Data quality | Whatever arrived | Enforced by rules on the way in |
| Storage cost | Low, object storage | Higher, managed by the platform |
| Common platforms | ADLS Gen2, Amazon S3, Google Cloud Storage | Fabric Warehouse, Snowflake, BigQuery, Redshift, Synapse |
How to Decide
Microsoft's Fabric decision guide compares a Fabric warehouse with a lakehouse on three points. AWS's comparison adds the typical workloads.
- Data type. Microsoft says structured data only points to a warehouse. Unstructured or semi-structured data, or uncertainty about the mix, points to a lake.
- Skills. A T-SQL team fits a warehouse. A team that works in Spark, using Python, Scala, Spark SQL or R, fits a lake.
- Transactions. A need for multi-table transactions points to a warehouse.
- Workload. AWS pairs warehouses with batch reporting and BI, and lakes with machine learning, exploration and streaming.
We add one more, because it decides most cases on its own. Who runs the queries, and how often do they repeat? A fixed set of reports run by the same people every week is a warehouse. Open-ended questions asked once by people who can write code is a lake. Most companies have both kinds of question, which is why most of them end up with both.
Three Common Situations
A company whose data comes from an ERP, a CRM and a few line-of-business databases, and whose goal is reliable monthly and weekly reporting, needs a warehouse. A lake adds cost and skills it will not use. This describes most of the mid-size companies we work with.
A company with application logs, clickstreams or machine data that it wants to analyse, keep for compliance, or use to train models needs a lake. A warehouse would either reject the data or make storing it expensive.
A company that has the first situation today and expects the second within two years should build the warehouse on a lake, which is where the lakehouse pattern comes in. In Microsoft Fabric that is the default: both a lakehouse and a warehouse store their tables in OneLake, so adding the second later does not mean moving the data.
A Word on Cost
AWS describes lake storage as low-cost, with compute and storage decoupled. It credits a warehouse's fastest results to local storage. That points to cheaper storage on the lake side and more predictable query cost on the warehouse side.
We will not put a multiple on the gap. It depends on your query patterns and vendor pricing, and we have not found a figure from Microsoft, AWS or Databricks solid enough to repeat. Two things we can say. Storage is rarely the biggest line on either bill. Compute is, and compute follows how many queries run and how well the data is laid out for them. And a lake that nobody has organized costs more to query than its storage price suggests, because every query reads more files than it needs. Ask for a workload-specific estimate before budgeting either way.
Data Lake vs Data Warehouse vs Data Lakehouse
The three-way comparison comes up because the lakehouse is the vendors' answer to this whole question. A lakehouse keeps data in lake storage, as open-format files, and adds a table format that gives those files transactions and schema enforcement. It is a lake that can be queried like a warehouse.
For the decision in this post, treat the lakehouse as a lake with a warehouse-shaped layer on top. If your answer above was "warehouse", a lakehouse does not change it: you still need the modelling and the curated tables, and a managed warehouse may do it with fewer moving parts. If your answer was "both", a lakehouse is how most platforms deliver both on one copy of the data. Our lakehouse guide covers the architecture.
Data Lake vs Data Warehouse vs Data Mart
A data mart is a subset of a warehouse built for one department or one subject: a sales mart, a finance mart. AWS's comparison describes it as a smaller, focused version of the warehouse, often fed from it. Marts are not an alternative to the lake-or-warehouse choice. They are how a warehouse is served to the people who use it. A company that asks for "a data mart" usually needs a warehouse first and a mart as its first delivery.
Why the Choice Is Blurring
A Dremio survey, conducted by Propeller Insights in the fourth quarter of 2024, asked 563 IT decision-makers about their plans. 67% plan to run the majority of their analytics on data lakehouses within three years, up from 55% today. Dremio sells lakehouse software, so read the number as a direction.
The direction is real, though. Snowflake now supports Iceberg tables in your own storage, Microsoft Fabric stores warehouse tables in OneLake as Delta files, and Databricks has sold the lakehouse since 2020. The platforms are converging on lake storage with warehouse behaviour on top. The decision in this post still matters, because it decides what you build on that storage: a modelled, governed set of tables for reporting, or a raw landing zone for engineering, or both in sequence.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a data lake and a data warehouse? A data lake stores raw data of any type and applies structure when it is read. A data warehouse stores cleaned, structured data with the structure defined before loading. Lakes suit engineering and exploration. Warehouses suit repeatable reporting.
Can a company use both a warehouse and a lake? Yes. A lake can hold raw and exploratory data while a warehouse serves the reports people run every week. Microsoft Fabric supports both on the same storage.
Which one does Microsoft Fabric push companies toward? Neither by default. Microsoft's guidance is to choose based on data type, team skills and transaction needs. Both items store their data in OneLake.
What are the benefits of a data warehouse? Trusted numbers that agree across reports, fast and predictable queries, and data that business users can work with through BI tools without writing code. The cost is the design work up front.
Is a data lake cheaper than a data warehouse? Storage is cheaper. AWS describes lake storage as low-cost. Compute costs depend on what you run against it, so the total varies by workload.
What is schema-on-read versus schema-on-write? Schema-on-write defines the structure before data is stored, which is the warehouse approach. Schema-on-read applies it when you query, which is the lake approach.
Is Databricks a data warehouse or a lakehouse? Databricks calls its platform a lakehouse. It runs warehouse-style SQL on Delta tables stored in your cloud storage rather than in a separate warehouse.
Do we need a data engineer for either one? In our view, a warehouse can run with less specialized setup once it is built. A lake, especially with a table format on top, benefits from someone who has built one before.
What is the first question to ask before choosing? Ask who runs the queries, and how often they repeat. A fixed, recurring report points to a warehouse. An open-ended question points to a lake.
Not sure which one fits your company? Talk to Alphabyte before you commit to either, or see our Microsoft Fabric consulting page if you plan to build on Fabric.